Day 2 and 3 prospects the Giants should target.
We’re just under two weeks away from the 2025 NFL Draft, and much of the attention surrounding the New York Giants revolves around the third overall pick. But while fans and analysts speculate about the top selection, it’s often the middle rounds that truly shape a roster.
Historically, the Giants have struggled with their Day 2 and 3 picks—until 2024, when their selections beyond the first round received high praise. Players like Tyler Nubin, Dru Phillips, Theo Johnson, and Tyrone Tracy now project as 2025 starters. Replicating that mid-round success will be key for Joe Schoen and Brian Daboll if they hope to solidify the team’s foundation.
Here are five mid-round prospects the Giants should target:
Tyler Shough – QB, Louisville
Despite adding Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston, the Giants may still look to draft a developmental quarterback. Shough, a 25-year-old with experience at Oregon, Texas Tech, and Louisville, brings maturity and upside. With veterans ahead of him, he could learn in 2025 and potentially take over in 2026. If the Giants pass on a QB early, Shough is a strong Day 2 option.
Donovan Jackson – OL, Ohio State
The Giants’ offensive line depth remains a concern. With past mid-round misses like Marcus McKethan and Joshua Ezeudu, the team can’t afford another whiff. Jackson, who played guard and tackle at Ohio State, visited the Giants pre-draft and could be a long-term replacement for underperforming veterans like Jon Runyan. His physical style makes him an ideal fit for a rebuild up front.
Kaleb Johnson – RB, Iowa
With uncertainty in the backfield, Johnson could be the perfect complement to Tyrone Tracy. As a power back with finesse, he fits the Giants’ new committee approach. If players like Eric Gray or Devin Singletary move on post-draft, Johnson could step into a meaningful role.
Alfred Collins – DL, Texas
Dexter Lawrence needs help inside, and Collins could be it. While not a prolific pass rusher, Collins is a reliable run-stopper—a trait the Giants sorely lacked after trading Leonard Williams. He would bring size and consistency alongside Lawrence.
Marcus Mbow – OL, Purdue
Injuries continue to plague the Giants’ offensive line. Mbow, who has experience at right tackle and could move to guard, offers athleticism and versatility. With Andrew Thomas missing significant time in recent years, adding depth with someone like Mbow could be crucial for stability in the trenches.
If the Giants can strike gold again in the middle rounds, they’ll be on track for long-term improvement.
Leave a Reply